Article

Hiring a Compliance Manager in Financial Services: What to Look For

8 Minutes

Hiring a compliance manager in financial services means looking for relevant regulatory knowledge, sound judgement and the ability to challenge decisions constructively. Effective compliance recruitment starts with understanding your firm’s activities, the risks the person will oversee and the authority they need to do the job.

A candidate may have an impressive CV, recognised qualifications and experience at a major financial institution. However, those credentials do not automatically establish whether they can support your products, customers and business model.

This guide explains how to define the appointment, assess candidates and build a hiring process around the capabilities your organisation needs.


Start with the business behind the vacancy

Successful financial services recruitment requires a clear understanding of the organisation behind the job title. A compliance manager supporting an investment bank may need different experience from someone joining a retail lender, asset manager or growing fintech.

Before approaching candidates, establish why you are hiring. Are you replacing an experienced team member, strengthening oversight of a new product or addressing weaknesses identified through monitoring? Each situation creates a different brief.

For example, a firm expanding into a new market may need someone who can interpret unfamiliar requirements and coordinate implementation. An established business with overdue monitoring actions may need stronger testing, reporting and remediation experience.

Your compliance staffing plan should identify:

  • The legal entities, products and jurisdictions within scope.
  • The customers and distribution channels the role will cover.
  • The existing team structure and reporting line.
  • The most significant compliance risks and outstanding actions.
  • The decisions the manager will own and those they will escalate.
  • The resources and specialist support available.

Use these details to define what the person must achieve during their first six months. This gives hiring managers a practical basis for assessing suitability.


Define the scope of your compliance recruitment brief

Compliance manager jobs can cover advisory work, monitoring, regulatory change, policy development or a combination of responsibilities. Advertising a broad role without explaining the balance makes it harder to attract suitable applicants.

Decide whether the appointment is primarily responsible for advising the business, independently assessing controls or managing a team. If several responsibilities sit together, explain how the workload will be prioritised.

Also distinguish compliance responsibilities from adjacent functions. Financial crime, operational risk, internal audit and legal teams may work closely with compliance, but experience in one area does not automatically demonstrate competence in another.

The FCA Handbook’s compliance provisions address the responsibilities and independence of compliance functions, with requirements varying by firm type. Check which provisions apply when defining the role’s authority, access to information and reporting arrangements.

For regulatory compliance recruitment, the brief should make clear where the individual will sit within that structure. A manager supporting a head of compliance has a different mandate from someone leading the function.


Look for regulatory knowledge relevant to your firm

Strong candidates should be able to explain how relevant requirements affect business decisions, processes and controls.

A list of regulatory acronyms on a CV offers limited evidence. Ask candidates which requirements they have worked with, what they were personally responsible for and how they assessed whether their approach was effective.

Depending on your activities, relevant experience might include:

  • Retail conduct and customer outcomes.
  • Investment services and trading activity.
  • Financial promotions and distribution.
  • Conflicts of interest.
  • Compliance monitoring and management information.
  • Regulatory reporting or regulatory change.

Avoid turning this into a requirement for expertise in every area. Separate essential knowledge from experience that could be developed with appropriate support.


Test how candidates apply their knowledge

Use a scenario connected to your business. For example, ask how they would assess a proposed change to a product’s distribution arrangements.

A useful answer should explore the product, intended customers, applicable requirements, available evidence and potential risks before recommending action. Follow up by asking what they would document, who they would involve and when they would escalate concerns.

This helps reveal whether the candidate can translate technical knowledge into proportionate advice.


Assess monitoring, investigation and follow-through

A compliance manager needs to identify weaknesses and help ensure they receive appropriate attention. Finding an issue is only part of the work.

Ask candidates to describe a monitoring review they delivered. Explore how they selected the area, defined the testing, evaluated evidence and reported findings.

Then examine what happened afterwards:

  • Who took ownership of the corrective action?
  • How were deadlines and priorities agreed?
  • What happened when an action became overdue?
  • How did they establish whether the underlying problem had been resolved?

Look for clear explanations of personal responsibility. “We improved the framework” should lead to questions about what the candidate actually designed, reviewed or challenged.

Effective regulatory compliance recruitment should assess the quality of these decisions. Completing a monitoring programme on schedule is useful, but employers also need to understand whether it examined the right risks and produced findings the business could act on.

A candidate who can explain limitations in their evidence, as well as their conclusions, may demonstrate stronger judgement than someone who presents every review as straightforward.

Evaluate challenge, communication and judgement

Compliance managers need to communicate concerns to people with different priorities and levels of technical understanding. They may advise product teams, challenge senior stakeholders and explain findings to governance committees.

Ask for an example of a decision they challenged. Explore the concern, the evidence they gathered, the response they received and the eventual outcome.

Strong answers should show that the candidate could explain the issue clearly, listen to relevant information and maintain an appropriate position under pressure. They should also recognise when escalation was necessary.

A short writing exercise can help. Give candidates an anonymised set of findings and ask them to prepare a brief management update covering:

  • The issue and why it matters.
  • The evidence and any uncertainties.
  • The recommended action.
  • The decision or support required.

Keep the exercise proportionate and use the same assessment criteria for everyone. You are testing whether someone can make a complex issue understandable and actionable.


Check qualifications, development and regulatory status

Relevant qualifications can support a candidate’s technical foundation. However, employers should assess them alongside practical experience and continuing professional development.

Ask what the candidate has studied, how it relates to the vacancy and how they maintain their knowledge. A useful discussion will connect learning to changes they have made in their work.

The FCA’s guidance on heads of compliance and money laundering reporting officers considers training, experience and the capacity to fulfil those particular roles. It provides useful context when recruiting for a position with that level of responsibility.


Does the appointment involve a senior management function?

A compliance manager title does not, by itself, establish whether FCA approval is required.

The FCA explains that the requirement for a compliance oversight function, SMF16, depends on the firm’s regulatory status, type and permissions. Confirm the position against the applicable rules before setting the recruitment and onboarding timetable.

Where relevant, use the FCA’s Senior Managers Regime guidance to inform your planning.

Your brief should distinguish between supporting an existing senior manager and taking responsibility for the function. This affects the experience you need, the assessment process and the checks required before the individual starts.


Choose the right compliance staffing approach

Permanent hiring, interim cover and project support serve different purposes. The appropriate choice depends on the work, its duration and the accountability involved.

A permanent appointment may suit an ongoing need for business knowledge, stakeholder relationships and team leadership. Interim support may help cover an absence or provide capacity while a permanent search progresses. A defined project may call for specialist experience in a particular review or remediation programme.

Before choosing your compliance staffing approach, ask:

  • Is the requirement ongoing or linked to a specific deliverable?
  • Does the role involve managing people or holding formal responsibilities?
  • How quickly must the individual become effective?
  • What handover and internal support will be available?
  • How will knowledge transfer take place?

Urgency should make the brief more focused. Identify which capabilities are essential from day one and which can be supported internally.


Make compliance manager jobs clear and credible

Well-written compliance manager jobs should help candidates understand the appointment’s responsibilities, authority and working environment.

Include the reporting line, team structure, principal activities and expected outcomes. Explain whether the person will inherit an established programme, build new processes or address known weaknesses.

Be realistic about the breadth of the role. A vacancy combining technical advice, monitoring, financial crime oversight, regulatory change and team leadership needs a credible explanation of the support available.

Experienced candidates may also ask how concerns are escalated, how compliance interacts with commercial teams and whether senior leaders act on findings. Prepare specific answers.

This is an important part of financial services recruitment: candidates are assessing whether the organisation will enable them to carry out the responsibilities described.


Use a structured assessment process

Agree the assessment criteria before reviewing applications. This keeps the search focused and helps interviewers compare evidence consistently.

For compliance recruitment, a practical scorecard could cover:

 

Assessment area

Evidence to look for

Relevant experience

Work involving comparable products, customers or activities

Regulatory knowledge

Clear explanations of how requirements affect the business

Monitoring capability

Risk assessment, testing, reporting and action tracking

Judgement

Proportionate decisions, recognised limitations and appropriate escalation

Communication

Clear advice and constructive challenge

Leadership, where required

Prioritisation, delegation and development of others


Use the same core questions for each candidate, with follow-up questions tailored to their experience. Record the evidence behind your assessment.

Before making an offer, confirm the checks applicable to the appointment and allow time for references, notice periods and any required approval process. Agree a clear handover and initial priorities so the successful candidate can begin with an informed understanding of the role.


Strengthen your compliance recruitment with McGregor Boyall

McGregor Boyall supports financial services organisations with appointments across compliance, governance and legal functions. Our compliance recruitment specialists work with employers to identify professionals whose experience matches the role's responsibilities.

Whether you are planning a permanent appointment or reviewing your wider compliance staffing requirements, contact our team to discuss the expertise your business needs.

If you are exploring compliance manager jobs, visit our latest vacancies and search for opportunities relevant to your experience.


Frequently asked questions

What should employers look for when hiring a compliance manager?

Employers should look for relevant regulatory knowledge, experience with comparable business activities and evidence of sound judgement. Candidates should be able to explain how they assess risks, challenge decisions, communicate findings and follow through on corrective actions.

What qualifications does a compliance manager need?

Qualification requirements depend on the role and the firm. Relevant compliance or financial crime qualifications may support an application, but employers should also assess practical experience, continuing development and competence for the specific responsibilities involved.

Does every compliance manager need FCA approval?

No. A job title alone does not determine whether approval is required. Employers must establish whether the appointment involves an applicable senior management function and check the requirements for their firm and the responsibilities being allocated.

How does regulatory compliance recruitment differ across financial services?

Regulatory compliance recruitment varies by the firm’s products, customers, permissions, and jurisdictions. A role supporting retail lending may require different knowledge from one overseeing investment activities. The hiring brief should identify the experience essential to the specific business.

How can a financial services recruitment specialist support compliance hiring?

A financial services recruitment specialist can help clarify the brief, identify relevant candidate experience and coordinate the search and assessment process. Employers remain responsible for determining suitability and completing the checks and approvals applicable to the appointment.